How to Turn Your Kids into Radicals
It started as a joke.
It was Friday night, which in our family means pizza and movie night. It’s the only video time our kids get–we don’t watch television, video games, or any of that–just one movie, as a family event. My son, eight years old, was skeptical of the idea of watching Pete’s Dragon, which had arrived from Netflix that week. So my partner, mostly as a joke, said, “Well, if you don’t want to watch that, you can watch our movie, Food Incorporated.”
My son stopped. “What’s that about?”
We explained that it was a documentary about what is wrong with the food industry, and the bad things that big corporations do to farmers and food.
“That sounds interesting, I want to know what is wrong with our food.” His ten-year old sister completely agreed.
So we gathered in the living room and watched it together, both children totally focused on the movie, learning about factory farms, food-borne illnesses, corn-fed vs grass-fed cows, and agribusiness. My son did start to lose interest about 15 minutes from the end, when the more abstract issues of Genetically Modified Organisms went a little over his eight-year old head, (and frankly it wasn’t the strongest part of the movie). At the end we read off the long list of ways to help and change the system, and they got up resolving to write their own books about the problems with the food industry (And I was really glad that we were eating home-made, vegetarian pizza with nearly all organic ingredients from the food co-op–which spared me the image of two outraged children demanding to know why we would be feeding them corporate food).
The really amazing thing is that this really was their idea. We didn’t particularly encourage them to watch it–we warned them that there might be a lot of sad or gross pictures from the insides of slaughterhouses, and were a little worried that they might not be ready for it. But they really wanted to see it–they wanted to know more about what was wrong with the world, and left wanting to do something about it.
Though I have been a progressive for most of my adult life, I haven’t been trying to push my politics around my children. Since they were born I haven’t been much of an activist. When Seattle’s activist community was preparing for the WTO protests, I was preparing for the birth of my first child, and saving vacation to extend paternity leave. I took my daughter to a couple of protests against the Afghanistan war when she was a toddler, riding on my back–but the anger of the protest frightened her, and I didn’t want her to grow up thinking that protests were something scary. When my son came along, I found myself pretty well consumed by the day-to-day concerns of raising two children in a healthy and caring way.
Oh, we’ve made clear what we feel about things. They grew up knowing that George Bush was a bad President, and, at an age appropriate level, why. We taught them why we feel war is wrong, why we eat organic food, why we drive a hybrid car and try to use the bus whenever we can. We talked about racism and pollution and global warming. We read them books about saving the environment, about people’s lives around the world, and the incredible children’s books of Patricia Polacco and Dr. Suess (The Lorax and The Butter Battle are still some of the most political kid’s books out there). We played them children’s music by Dana Lyons.
They have certainly grown up surrounded by progressive values, but we haven’t really tried to push a lot of politics onto the kids. In part, because their ability to understand some of the more abstract concepts is still growing, but mostly because it feels wrong; trying to push political views on a child goes against the grain of any sort of liberatory politics. You can’t force people to be radicals; they have to choose that path themselves. All we can do is lay the seeds.
What we have done, is to teach our values: values of compassion, of kindness, of fairness, of respect. We have tried to teach them that who they are as people matters. We have tried to give them appropriate limits and rules, which kids need, and a safe and healthy space in which to live. We teach them not to hurt others, not to hit, not to tease or put people down, and that nobody should hurt them. And we love them, and listen, which is the most important part of all.
Parenting is an ultimate act of faith and trust. We are entrusted with the life of another human being who is totally dependent on us for everything. We are entrusted to care for that life, to give that human being the love and nurturing they need, and to fill their world with wonder and magic. We are entrusted with helping them grow: first to walk and talk, then to figure out how the world works, how to come into their own as a person, and eventually to eventually go off into that world on their own. And we need to have faith-faith in our own ability to do this incredibly daunting task, faith in the wonderful people they are, and faith in the wonderful people they will become. Parenting also means a lot of pain and a lot of tears, from skinned knees to broken hearts, and it’s the parents who fall down and fail as much as the kids. In the end, we know that they need to figure out what they believe in for themselves, and we ultimately have no control over that (in the heart of every progressive parent, I think there is a little part that says: what will I do if they become Republicans?)
So when an eight- and a ten-year-old child, our children, decide to watch a political documentary because they want to know what is wrong with the world, I feel like maybe, just maybe, I am doing the right thing after all.
Sometimes, though, the most radical things we do are the most everyday and ordinary, and often the most important. Which brings me to a story about my daughter.
A week or two before we watched Food Inc., my daughter brought home a note from a girl in her class, thanking her for standing up for this girl against the teasing of some other classmates. We asked what had happened, and found out that my daughter’s three closest friends were among the girls doing the teasing. Which means that my daughter, at ten years old, stood up to her best friends to do what is right. I can remember times in my twenties when I didn’t have that kind of courage.
I would love to take credit for that, and say that it was a result of how we raised her. I hope that to some extent it is. But I also know that she has an inner strength and a sense of self that is deeply her own, (and that she has faith in her friends, who really are good kids despite getting caught up in this dynamic).
When a ten-year-old has the courage to stand up for what is right against a playground injustice, it makes me think: that kid will change the world some day. But that sells her short; she is already changing the world, right here and now, and when she and her generation come into their own, this world is going to be in good hands. –John Chapman
Comments
By Lansing Scott on September 10th, 2010 at 3:33 am
Sweet & wise story.
I’m not so convinced by final sentence, though; a lot of kids are being raised in much less nurturing environments. Some kids’ have natural curiosity & critical thinking encouraged; some stifled. Roughly proportional to the parents who raise them.
Overall, could the next generation do worse than current generation? Or better? That’s still an open question, I think.
By Holly on September 10th, 2010 at 9:52 am
Nice work dad and good food for thought.
I think you are doing great work in demonstrating values and setting appropriate boundaries. As your children grow older, and the boundaries go further, I suspect if you continue to be open, honest and connected with your children, they will continue to model you and make good choices.
I chuckle a little and shake my head though at the thought:
“in the heart of every progressive parent, I think there is a little part that says: what will I do if they become Republicans?”
Well, one never knows, however I sincerely hope my children will never choose a label, but instead remain open-minded thinkers. I think I would be just as appalled if they chose “liberal”, “democrat” or “progressive” versus republican, as it is all too easy to close your mind once you are willing to adopt a label. And while we may think it is all good and well to close our minds to republican idealisms for instance, we are missing the point of progressive if we do.
The faith part or parenting comes as children grow and make choices deviating from your own! I know I find it terrifying but remind myself it is what I am training my children to do: Think for themselves. And keep my thought processes active as well. While it is not often I am confronted by my 9 year old, I try to always be open to good argument and reconsideration with him, as I think the most important thing I can teach my kids is to look carefully at their choices, the effects or consequences, and the root of their actions. (Boundaries are still intact of course, but the dialogue is there.)
Lance, I don’t think there really is any better or worse generation to be quite honest. I think there are changes taking place all the time that are better for some, worse for others. I don’t know that I can articulate this very well, but essentially what I am getting at is human nature seems to be relatively consistent and thus, we continue to repeat history again, and again, just a different backdrop. I think you can choose where you want to be on stage, but in turn, this will also change your perspective, and puts as back at the question: is it better or worse? Well, probably just the same, you just have a new view.
By geov on September 10th, 2010 at 10:59 pm
To me this thread ties in with today’s blog item, on a under-six soccor team called “Shock and Awe,” in a league where the games supposedly don’t keep score and it’s in theory all about socializing preschoolers and teaching teamwork and fair play. Instead you have a group of parents who named the team and who are embracing (in how the kids are encouraged to play as well) pulverizing an opponent – and glorifying war crimes in the process. Moral: different kids get vastly different messages from their parents and other mentors on how to relate to other people, process information, and navigate a confusing world. And trends in those messages do change from generation to generation. I like John’s approach a lot better than that of the soccer parents in Montlake.
It’s always hard to know what to do, though. Threads like this one always remind me of the quote of parenting being the most difficult job known to humanity where the only entry requirement is unskilled labor.
By Cranky Prole Bitch on September 12th, 2010 at 12:45 pm
Only a guy would call it “unskilled!”
By geov on September 13th, 2010 at 7:18 am
@ CPB The reference is to the original conception, not to giving birth.
By John Chapman on September 13th, 2010 at 9:10 am
Wow – thanks for all the thoughtful comments.
Holly – I definitely hope my kids will remain open minded and thoughtful of whatever path they take. I am not as concerned about labels though. Provided that the label remains a rough guidepost and not a cage, I think they are a useful shorthand. They help to identify a set of positions that share a common goal, if not a rigidly unified one. Being part of a progressive community is a way of claiming a commonality and certain shared values. And I do think communities need labels and identity, if only to make it a little easier than rattling off all of ones beliefs all the time.
There is a quote from the artist R.B. Kataj to the effect of – “We all belong to tribes. Only dillitantes can pretend to be universal” (from memory, so I won’t swear I got it right). I find that this rings true in two ways. First, that we are always marked by the community, culture and language of which we are a part, and pretensions of universal understanding are often based on a colonial notion that ones own position is somehow “above” that of other people and cultures. Second, and equally important, is the realization that who we are is to a great extent formed by the people and community we are connected with. Those connections are as important to being fully human, and to being a positive force for change, as any abstract principles or critical viewpoints. So long as it remains a source of strength, not a chain, then we it’s OK embrace our “tribes” and build on the shoulders of each other. When the community becomes a cult, then it is time to move on.
Lance – I don’t think we know what this current group of kids will become, and like all generations they will be diverse. But I think that this is a truly remarkable generation. Teenagers today are probably the least racist and homophobic generation in the history of this country. Yes, they are incredibly wired and techno-centered, and may have shorter attention spans. But they are also incredibly networked and recognise their interconnections with each other. They reject mainstream media for a more interconnected and grass-roots approach to information, though that may be distorted as well. And they are growing up in an era when the reality of global change is more and more unavoidable. My biggest fear is that the prolonged weak economy and lack of opportunity will lead to increaing fear and dispair, rather than anger and a search for alternatives. I suspect they will have some hard questions for their elders, and will be willing to listen to sensible answers.
John
By Alexander Jordan on November 20th, 2011 at 10:48 pm
Thanks for the article. It was properly believed out and truly brought household your points. This really is just the information that I was seeking.